How to Deal with and Exploit the Unpredictable
Reflections #11
Welcome to this week's edition of Reflections. In a world where uncertainty is not just a possibility but a constant, it’s crucial to understand how to navigate and even exploit the unpredictable. Nassim Nicholas Taleb’s The Black Swan offers profound insights into how we can approach rare, high-impact events—both positive and negative—without being paralysed by our inability to predict them.
1. Focus on Consequences, Not Probabilities
Taleb emphasises that it’s not about predicting the likelihood of an event, but about understanding its potential consequences. As he explains through an earthquake example: you may not know the odds of an earthquake hitting San Francisco, but you can still prepare for its impact by taking actions like buying insurance or diversifying your investments.
His approach is rooted in what Taleb calls a general idea of uncertainty. We can’t compute the odds of rare events like financial crashes or technological breakthroughs, but we can mitigate their consequences by preparing for both positive and negative outcomes.
"You need to focus on the consequences of an event, even if we do not have a clear idea of how likely it is to occur."
This mindset shifts decision-making from trying to predict specific outcomes to preparing for their potential impact.
2. Embrace Asymmetric Outcomes
One of the central ideas from the text is that asymmetry is key to dealing with unpredictability. This means positioning yourself in situations where favourable consequences are much larger than unfavourable ones.
Positive Asymmetry: In fields like venture capital or publishing, where positive Black Swans (unexpected successes) are possible, you want to maximise exposure to these opportunities. Taleb likens this strategy to collecting “free lottery tickets”—you don’t need many winners if the payoff is large enough.
Negative Asymmetry: On the flip side, industries like banking or insurance are more prone to negative Black Swans (unexpected disasters). Here, your goal should be to minimise exposure to downside risks while remaining cautious about overconfidence.
"Put yourself in situations where favourable consequences are much larger than unfavourable ones."
This principle helps ensure that even if you cannot predict rare events, you stand to benefit from them when they occur.
3. Seize any Opportunity, or Anything that Looks Like Opportunity
Opportunities are often disguised as something else entirely and they are rare, much rarer than you think. Taleb stresses that you must be open-minded enough to recognise them when they appear and take advantage of them. He suggests that you should:
Expose yourself to serendipity: Attend conferences, engage in casual conversations—these seemingly random events can lead to breakthroughs.
Don’t discard opportunities prematurely: Once an opportunity starts paying off, continue maximising your exposure until it fully plays out.
This idea ties into what Taleb calls "stochastic tinkering," where trial-and-error allows for unexpected discoveries without trying to predict specific outcomes.
"Effectively... free markets have been successful because they allow the trial-and-error process I call stochastic tinkering."
By embracing randomness and experimentation, you increase your chances of stumbling upon valuable opportunities.
4. Beware of Overconfidence in Negative-Swan-Prone Industries
In industries where negative Black Swans are more likely (such as finance or insurance), Taleb warns against overconfidence. He points out that governments and large institutions often fail at predicting rare events because they rely too heavily on precise plans that don’t account for true uncertainty.
Stay cautious and avoid overextension: Don’t assume you can predict or control every risk.
Be sceptical of institutional forecasts: Governments and corporations often make plans based on incomplete data or flawed assumptions. Instead of trusting their predictions, focus on broad preparedness.
"In the end we are being driven by history, all the while thinking that we are doing the driving."
This quote serves as a reminder that despite our best efforts, we are often at the mercy of forces beyond our control.
5. Avoid Precision—It’s a Trap
One of Taleb’s most important lessons is that trying to predict with precision in areas dominated by uncertainty is a fool’s errand.
Don’t focus on exact outcomes: Instead of trying to predict which specific event will happen, focus on positioning yourself so that any positive surprise benefits you while any negative surprise doesn’t wipe you out.
Infinite vigilance isn’t possible: You cannot foresee every risk or opportunity; instead, focus on broad preparedness rather than narrow prediction.
"Do not waste your time trying to fight forecasters."
Taleb advises against relying too much on precise predictions because they can lead us astray when rare events inevitably occur.
Conclusion
Uncertainty doesn’t have to be feared—it can be harnessed and exploited if approached correctly. Whether you're navigating positive or negative Black Swans, the key lies in recognising uncertainty for what it is: an opportunity for those who are prepared and a trap for those who aren’t. By focusing on consequences rather than probabilities and embracing asymmetry in your decisions, you can turn unpredictability from a threat into an advantage.
ICYMI
Previous Reflections:
Our investing philosophy:
![Our Investing Philosophy [Free Checklist]](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_140,h_140,c_fill,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep,g_auto/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F43eb5ad6-6a32-45eb-989a-5f929c2b740d_1080x1080.png)
If you like our work and you’re interested in the types of companies we invest in, check out or most recent portfolio update here:
We hope you enjoyed this post. If you found it valuable, feel free to share it, and stay tuned for our next edition!
Until next week, happy investing.
The S.C. Team
Disclaimer: The content provided in this newsletter is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or other professional advice. The opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Schwar Capital. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The author may or may not hold positions in the stocks or other financial instruments mentioned. Always do your own research or consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions.